BRIMBANK NORTH WEST
Home » Uncategorized » Baby tragedy: Coroner cites Sunshine Hospital’s failure

Baby tragedy: Coroner cites Sunshine Hospital’s failure

A HEARTBROKEN mother has welcomed a coroner’s finding that her baby’s death could have been prevented if staff at Sunshine Hospital had monitored her more closely.

But Shashi Madamshetty said nothing could be done to undo the despair and trauma she and her husband had endured since the loss of their daughter Dishita in 2007.

“We are somewhat relieved by the coroner’s findings, but we still feel the loss of Dishita every day; it never fades,” the Footscray resident told the Weekly.

“We came to Australia to receive the best possible neonatal care for our precious baby, but in the end we lost her due to poor care.

“Nothing that happens after her death will ever bring her back.”

Coroner Kim Parkinson last week said Sunshine Hospital’s failure to increase foetal monitoring had contributed to the baby’s death.

Ms Madamshetty, 35, and her husband Vasu, 42, had been trying to conceive for eight years. They went to India to conceive through in-vitro fertilisation in November 2006.

“We were desperate and wanted a baby more than anything,” she said.

They returned to Australia for antenatal and obstetric care.

On August 23, 2007, Ms Madamshetty was three days overdue when she went to Sunshine Hospital with period-like pains, bleeding and a headache.

She wanted to undergo a caesarean section because of her concerns about the high-risk nature of her “fragile pregnancy” but was told to go home and was discharged.

She returned to the hospital on August 27 for a scheduled antenatal appointment and complained of an upper respiratory infection but was again sent home.

“I was told to go get some cough medicine, rest and see my GP,” she said. “But I knew something was wrong.”

Three days later, Dishita was delivered by caesarean section at the hospital. Dishita was born in poor condition and transferred to the Royal Children’s Hospital, where she died on September 30 of hypoxic brain injury.

Handing down her report, Ms Parkinson said it was likely that had intervention to increase foetal monitoring occurred on August 27, the baby’s deteriorating condition would have been identified and her death would likely have been prevented.

She found there was no information available to the midwife performing cardiotocograph (CTG) monitoring of the baby’s foetal heart rate that Ms Madamshetty had been bleeding and that she had been in pain on August 23.

Ms Parkinson recommended the hospital adopt and publish formal procedures for CTG monitoring and supervision, including regular monitoring of foetal heart rates.

Ms Madamshetty said she still saw her daughter in the faces of other babies.

“Every time we see other babies we are reminded of Dishita. We are still devastated by the outcome. Nobody likes to share this type of thing, but I feel that I need to express it so this never happens to another family.”

Mr Madamshetty called for measures to be put in place so midwives and obstetric clinicians could have an overall picture of each individual pregnancy.

Western Health chief executive Kathryn Cook last week extended her sympathies to the Madamshettys.

She said Western Health was reviewing the coroner’s report and was committed to implementing its recommendations.

The Madamshettys are suing the hospital for medical negligence in the County Court.

Digital Editions


  • Wanted woman hands herself in

    Wanted woman hands herself in

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 206998 Police have revealed that a 27-year-old Tarneit woman who was wanted on warrant following a fatal house fire…

More News

  • Community Calendar

    Community Calendar

    Sunshine Lunar New Year Festival Celebrating the lunar calendar, a time of renewal and for friends and family to come together to celebrate the start of a new year. The…

  • Farewell to local landmark

    Farewell to local landmark

    Long-time Sunshine residents have responded to Brimbank council’s Emergency Order, issued last month, to fully demolish the former council building at 6–18 Alexandra Avenue in Sunshine. The Emergency Order comes…

  • Sydenham man arrested

    Sydenham man arrested

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 206998 Police have charged a 36-year-old Sydenham man after alleged attempted car theft and an assault in Coburg on 1 December 2025. It is…

  • Speedster caught

    Speedster caught

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 206998 A 21-year-old St Albans man was allegedly caught driving 194km/h in a 100km/h zone in Little River in the early morning of Tuesday…

  • Lions hang on

    Lions hang on

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 460947 Taylors Lakes did just enough to make it four wins in a row on Saturday in the Victorian Sub-District Cricket Association east-west. The…

  • Working bee event

    Working bee event

    The Friends of Kororoit Creek (FOKC) is hosting a working bee event on Tuesday 20 January at its B Street Wildflower Garden site. According to FOKC, volunteers will do a…

  • Help keep Blue-tongues safe

    Help keep Blue-tongues safe

    Spotting a blue-tongue lizard might cause a fright but it is no reason to be concerned, according to a nature educator. Susie Inglis from Nature West is encouraging people in…

  • Albion Station car park closure

    Albion Station car park closure

    The Albion Station car park will be closed from Monday 2 February to late 2026 as construction begins on the first stage of the Melbourne Airport Rail and the rebuilding…

  • From the archives

    From the archives

    Star Weekly looks back on the articles of our predecessors… 40 years ago 29 January, 1986 Angry Deer Park residents have taken action in a bid to stop proposed industrial…

  • Tigers’ settling in

    Tigers’ settling in

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 512549 Sunshine United is slowly getting the confidence back and with it wins are coming in the Victorian Turf Cricket Association Isaacs Howarth Shield.…