BRIMBANK NORTH WEST
Home » Uncategorized » Deer Park sheep owner jailed over animal cruelty

Deer Park sheep owner jailed over animal cruelty

A Deer Park sheep owner has been jailed for seven months after pleading guilty to 175 separate offences of cruelty and aggravated cruelty to animals under his care in 2012.

Magistrate Peter Mealy also banned Paul Matthew Hamilton from owning livestock for ten years and ordered him to pay $40,000 in costs for causing  “unreasonable pain and suffering”.

The Melbourne Magistrates Court heard between July 3 and 13 more than 40 sheep were found on two Kerang properties to be either dead or in such poor health immediate euthanasia was required. 

The Department of Environment and Primary Industries prosecuted the case in what they deemed “was one of the most serious and significant animal cruelty matters it has brought before the courts”.

It began as a contested hearing in Kerang Magistrates Court before Magistrate Mealy on February 10, but after seven days of evidence the accused changed his plea to guilty. 

After being told the accused was also pleading guilty to breaching two banning orders in NSW and Victoria, Magistrate Mealy ordered a psychiatric assessment be completed and adjourned the matter to Melbourne Magistrates Court on April 24 for sentencing.

They related to the management of approximately 2200 sheep in a farming enterprise that included an intensive lambing program in which hormones were administered to ewes with the intention of inducing two lambings a year instead of the usual one.

The accused pleaded guilty to aggravated cruelty in respect to these individual animals, admitting he failed to provide them with appropriate attention and husbandry, with the result being that each animal experienced unreasonable pain and suffering.

The accused also pleaded guilty to committing acts of cruelty upon animals in the flocks at each of the properties by failing to provide appropriate attention and husbandry, as well as driving a mob of 1000 sheep by land when they were in no condition to travel.  

Digital Editions


  • More than four walls

    More than four walls

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 530350 For people who are socially isolated, culturally diverse or part of the LGBTQIA+ community, finding a space where…

More News

  • Police cut concerns

    Police cut concerns

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 206998 Residents and local politicians have raised concerns over further cuts to counter hours at Keilor Downs Police Station as well as a lack…

  • Pink Angels comes to Brimbank

    Pink Angels comes to Brimbank

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 531534 The annual Pink Angels fundraiser, raising money for breast cancer patients, will be held in Brimbank for the first time next month. Money…

  • Smelly problem lingers

    Smelly problem lingers

    A strong odour resembling rotting meat continues to affect residents in the Sunshine-area, prompting questions about the Environment Protection Authority’s (EPA) enforcement on the companies responsible. As reported by Star…

  • Changing young lives

    Changing young lives

    Anglicare Victoria, the state’s largest provider of out-of-home care, has put out an urgent call to locals in the west to become foster carers. For Braybrook resident and foster carer…

  • Spring Hills ready to go

    Spring Hills ready to go

    Spring Hills got a taste of what the National Premier League women’s competition was like last season, and are keen for more. Spring Hills showed plenty of positive signs in…

  • Faces of the west

    Faces of the west

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 532074 Each week Star Weekly photographers are out and about capturing events and people across the west.

  • Community Calendar

    Community Calendar

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 533209 Polonia Cup Proudly hosted by the Western Eagles Football Club, this vibrant three-day tournament will run from Friday 20 February to Sunday 22…

  • Probus member callout

    Probus member callout

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 531674 Deer Park Probus Club is on the lookout for new members. President Peter Dimitrijevic said the club provides an opportunity for seniors in…

  • School fair fun

    School fair fun

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 532073 There’s growing excitement among students at St Augustine’s Primary School as the school’s community fair fast approaches. A variety of rides and attractions…

  • Thousands venerate sacred relics

    Thousands venerate sacred relics

    More than 17,000 people attended Quang Minh Temple in Braybrook last month to pay their respects to sacred relics of the Buddha dating back over 2500 years. The relics travelled…