Sunshine police stubby holder sackings sad, says academic

Last week’s sacking of three police officers for the production of 50 racist stubby holders at Sunshine police station in 2012 was saddening, according to Victoria University lecturer Elleni Bereded-Samuel.

The community engagement adviser from Ethiopia praised Victoria Police’s handling of the issue but said she was amazed that officers would put so much time and effort into a negative act.

High-ranking members faced disciplinary action over the stubby holders, which featured a cartoon mudfish – derogatory slang for Africans – and were circulated around the station. The stubby holders also read: “Sunshine police: Whoever says Sunshine brings happiness has never worked here”.

Ms Bereded-Samuel said: “It’s sad it has cost them their job, and it’s sad for their families. What really makes me sad is that we’ve spent a lot of time building bridges between Victoria Police and the African community.

“The majority of police are very decent and very respectful people. This kind of situation sets back the community.”

Thirteen employees were investigated and two constables dismissed, charged with improper conduct. A sergeant was dismissed on one count of disgraceful conduct.

Three sergeants from Sunshine have been transferred to different stations.

Six other members – an inspector, senior sergeant, sergeant, two senior constables and a constable – received admonishments.

Another senior sergeant is still under investigation. “It’s amazing that somebody would take the time to produce such things” Ms Bereded-Samuel said. “Racism in any community or workplace must not be tolerated.”

She called for further engagement between police and the African community.

All three dismissed officers have lodged appeals with the Police Review Services Board.

Brimbank’s Inspector Chris Gilbert, who was appointed after the controversy, said: “I should point out it was two years ago and the staff at Sunshine has changed a lot since then.

“There’s been a lot of work going on between police and various agencies in the community. We’ve made very strong connections.”