BRIMBANK NORTH WEST
Home » Classifieds » My View: Katrina Hall confronts sibling rivalry

My View: Katrina Hall confronts sibling rivalry

Sometimes I feel my most important job as a parent is to make sure that, while trying to kill each other, no one around here actually gets hurt.

A moment ago one went flying out of the other one’s bedroom, and then a door slammed with an amount of force that, I’ve learnt from experience, can only be evoked when a little sister tries to sneak out with something illicitly “borrowed” from the bigger one.

In sibling fight language, big, exaggerated punctuation-mark noises such as doors slamming and object-throwing means: “Mum, come. She’s. In. My. Room”.

Should I stay or go? Intervene, throw around some cross adult words such as “unacceptable”, “intolerable” or “grounded” and risk getting caught in the crossfire? Or let them battle it out until someone loses some skin?

Two minutes after pulling each other’s hair out, they’ll be making houses together on Minecraft. But it will take me hours to recover from the guilt of the scary-mum scream and the words: “Wait until your father gets home”. Such empty threats might have stopped us as kids but they are just embarrassing now.

Some experts say it’s natural for siblings to want to whack each other and in doing so they learn how to manage conflict and some of the more uncomfortable feelings on the emotional spectrum, like anger and frustration.

Others believe sibling rivalry, particularly bullying, can cause life-long psychological issues, including depression and low self-esteem. But most agree it is normal, not as in OK normal, but in the sense that it happens in most households.

While that is true, it nonetheless drives us parents crazy; we might have invented satellite navigation and phones that do everything for us, but not one of us has worked out a way to stop our kids from hurting each other.

The fact that so many of us grew up giving our siblings Chinese burns and now we’re the best of friends, doesn’t help. Often it was the sibling we butted heads against the most that we are, in adulthood, the closest to. But should the guilt of tickling a little sister until she can’t breathe be wiped away by excuses – it was familial bonding, or a primal way of toughening up the younger ones so they could deal with the toughies on the corner? Is that good enough?

Actually, I admit, it did sometimes feel good, as a five-year-old, to be able to dole out a subtle punch when someone lost my best Fanta yo-yo or took my last bit of Easter egg from the fridge.

My little brother once gave me a blood nose. Unfortunately it didn’t last long enough for the moment of triumph I was hoping for, which involved my parents coming home, seeing my face awash with blood and deciding on the spot to send the perpetrator to an orphanage. The blood dried up and I was labelled a dibby dobber. But I still do wonder where they were, those parents of ours. Why weren’t they home to see the carnage?

It all rings true, in a way, with Freud’s theory about sibling violence being used as a way of eradicating our competitors in the battle for parental love.

Yet I’m not so sure parental love is the motivating factor these days. It would only be an issue around here if we were tablet-shaped and our batteries were charged to capacity.

I think I’ll just leave them to it.

Digital Editions


  • Noise backlash

    Noise backlash

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 504582 Locals have raised concerns about a high-pitched noise device being used to deter rough sleepers at the Brimbank…

More News

  • St Albans garage fire

    St Albans garage fire

    Twenty-five firefighters fought a St Albans house fire on Saturday 28 February, with the fire’s cause to be investigated. Crews responded to the incident on Clarice Close about 1.50pm to…

  • Keilor’s winning move

    Keilor’s winning move

    Keilor held its nerves to come out on top and claim the Bowls Victoria weekend pennant, division 2, section 1 premiership on Saturday. After being so close in recent seasons,…

  • VTCA finals set

    VTCA finals set

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 465587 Finals spots are locked in for the Victorian Turf Cricket Association competitions. In the senior division, Deer Park sealed top spot with victory…

  • Shopping help for heart health

    Shopping help for heart health

    The Heart Foundation and the nutrition platform No Money No Time have launched a new partnership to help residents in the northern and western suburbs manage rising grocery costs while…

  • WorkSafe manual handling workshops

    WorkSafe manual handling workshops

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 183103 Hazardous manual handling is the greatest cause of workplace injuries in Victoria, according to WorkSafe. The state’s work safety regulator said it has…

  • EPA puts brands on notice over packaging waste

    EPA puts brands on notice over packaging waste

    Environmental Protection Authority Victoria (EPA) has lost patience with companies that fail to show how they are reducing packaging waste, warning they risk significant penalties if they don’t comply with…

  • AI imaginary friends no substitute for human connection

    AI imaginary friends no substitute for human connection

    Loneliness and social isolation are now recognised as major public health threats, imploring governments to explore technological solutions. Research from Monash University argues new AI ‘digital companions’ marketed as a…

  • Sporting club grants up for grabs

    Sporting club grants up for grabs

    Local sporting clubs across the state are encouraged to apply for a fresh round of funding grants launched by the state government. On Wednesday, Community Sport Minister Ros Spence announced…

  • F1 festival headed to Melbourne

    F1 festival headed to Melbourne

    A free Formula 1 Melbourne Fan Festival is coming to Federation Square. Tourism, Sport and Major Events Minister Steve Dimopoulos announced the free festival will make it easier and more…

  • CFA recruits wanted

    CFA recruits wanted

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 536638 Caroline Springs Fire Brigade is on the lookout for new recruits. “Whether you’re interested in responding to emergency calls, helping behind the scenes,…