BRIMBANK NORTH WEST
Home » News » Opposition grows against children in detention

Opposition grows against children in detention

A growing chorus of protest against Australia’s treatment of asylum seekers is building in Melbourne’s west.

Educators, grandmothers and refugee advocates descended on the office of Gellibrand MP Tim Watts last week to express dissatisfaction with both major political parties over their support for mandatory offshore detention of asylum seekers, including children.

The protest came in the wake of a High Court decision earlier this month affirming the government’s right to send asylum seekers to detention centres on Nauru and Manus Island.

Following the decision, Star Weekly reported that offshore processing was backed by both Gellibrand MP Tim Watts and federal Labor leader and Maribyrnong MP Bill Shorten.

More than 120 Victoria University staff and students signed a joint letter presented to Mr Watts on Thursday, asking him to follow Premier Daniel Andrews’ example and lobby for the 267 asylum-seeker men, women and children now in Australia, including 36 babies born here, not to be sent back to Nauru or Manus Island.

“We are extremely concerned about the physical, psychological and emotion wellbeing of this group, based on the ample evidence presented by health professionals, which clearly demonstrates that detention is very harmful,” the letter states.

“Australia’s harsh asylum seeker policy has been condemned by human rights advocates, medical professionals, educators and by international bodies as cruel and in violation of the UN Refugee Rights Charter.”

Morally unjustifiable

VU teacher and letter co-organiser letter Margarita Windisch said thousands of people have been rallying across the country calling on the federal government and the Labor opposition to ‘Let Them Stay’, culminating in the mass weekend vigil outside the Lady Cilento Children’s Hospital in Brisbane to prevent the deportation of ‘Baby Asha’ to Nauru.

“We, as educators and citizens, are very upset about the situation and upset about the fact our local representative Tim Watts has come out in support of offshore detention,” she said. “We think he’s out of step with community sentiment.

“We think it is morally unjustifiable to send children back to detention centres that will harm their wellbeing.”

Mr Watts said while he welcomed people’s compassion, a “regional solution” was needed to stop “a human tragedy in the seas”.

“Reasonable people of goodwill can look at the same set of facts in this complex issue and come to a different view.”

He said there must be more transparency and oversight in immigration detention centres; people’s asylum claims must be assessed more quickly and children’s rights must be protected.

Digital Editions


  • Aussie kids salt risk

    Aussie kids salt risk

    Research from Deakin University has suggested most Australian children are at risk of developing high blood pressure at a younger age due to eating too…

More News

  • Residents encouraged to mind water usage

    Residents encouraged to mind water usage

    Residents across Melbourne’s north and west are being called upon to reduce their water consumption as state storage levels fall to 61% of capacity. This current level marks a decrease…

  • Additional health test for newborns

    Additional health test for newborns

    Victoria has become the first Australian jurisdiction to include sickle cell disease in its universal newborn health screening program. This expansion brings the total number of rare but serious conditions…

  • More than four walls

    More than four walls

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 530350 For people who are socially isolated, culturally diverse or part of the LGBTQIA+ community, finding a space where you feel safe and welcomed…

  • Johns’ new challenge

    Johns’ new challenge

    One door closed and another opened for new Keilor Thunder signing Matt Johns. Johns, who had been playing in Queensland, was set to play basketball overseas late last year. When…

  • Forum supports women living with epilepsy across all life stages

    Forum supports women living with epilepsy across all life stages

    Epilepsy Action Australia and Australian Women with Epilepsy are inviting women across the country to take part in a powerful one-day forum designed to uplift, inform and support women living…

  • Funding to improve road safety across Victoria

    Funding to improve road safety across Victoria

    Victorian community organisations and groups will receive a total of $600,000 in grants from the Transport Accident Commission (TAC) to develop and implement local road safety projects. The funding, part…

  • Guitar virtuoso to take centre stage

    Guitar virtuoso to take centre stage

    The tiny, yet very mighty, Melbourne Chamber Orchestra is making its way to the west later this month. The orchestra will present its new show Flexible Sky, starring Slava Grigoryan,…

  • Police cut concerns

    Police cut concerns

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 206998 Residents and local politicians have raised concerns over further cuts to counter hours at Keilor Downs Police Station as well as a lack…

  • Pink Angels comes to Brimbank

    Pink Angels comes to Brimbank

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 531534 The annual Pink Angels fundraiser, raising money for breast cancer patients, will be held in Brimbank for the first time next month. Money…

  • Smelly problem lingers

    Smelly problem lingers

    A strong odour resembling rotting meat continues to affect residents in the Sunshine-area, prompting questions about the Environment Protection Authority’s (EPA) enforcement on the companies responsible. As reported by Star…