BRIMBANK NORTH WEST
Home » News » Dream home turns sour

Dream home turns sour

It was meant to be their dream house – double storey with four bedrooms in the coveted suburb of Taylors Hill.

But not long after moving into their Simonds Homes-built house in 2005, the Murugesu family said they started noticing cracks appearing on the interior walls.

Then the ceiling started to crack, tiles began to lift and the exterior walls cracked. The foundation of the house has now moved to such an extent, the family is unable to open some windows and doors, and close others.

The cracking on the outside walls has caused rain to seep inside the cladding, rusting some metal beams, as well as inside the house.

Picture Shawn Smits.

Viswanathan Murugesu took Star Weekly on a tour of the family home, revealing the extent of the damage, which includes curved walls and architraves.

“It was going to be our dream house, my wife was so happy,” Mr Murugesu says. “A few months later all the cracks started appearing.”

Mr Murugesu said he has contacted Simonds Homes several times over the years. He says the building company “patched up” the problems, without addressing the root cause of the issue or agreeing to rebuild the house.

Picture Shawn Smits.

But the building giant denies it’s not trying to resolve the issue.

Simonds Homes chief executive Kelvin Ryan said the company offered to fix the house in line with a report by an engineer engaged by Mr Murugesu.

“However, upon this offer by Simonds, the owner alleged that their engineer did not consider all issues with the home. Simonds suggested the owners re-engage their independent engineer at Simonds’ sole cost, to investigate issues in the home and produce a revised expert report, which identified the expert’s investigations, findings and approved rectification method,” Mr Ryan said.

“Then Simonds would again visit the owners to go through the report with them and agree to the approved rectification scope of work proposed in the report.

“To date, the owners are refusing to engage an expert to carry out these investigations because they want Simonds to agree upfront to demolish the home without seeing any detailed evidence.”

Mr Murugesu said he wants the soil tested, and the house demolished and rebuilt. He also wants a national inquiry into building and design guidelines.

Picture Shawn Smits.

Digital Editions


  • Crack down on dodgy drivers

    Crack down on dodgy drivers

    New reforms are being introduced to protect Victorian taxi or ride-share passengers from being ripped off. The reforms, which come into effect on Sunday 1…

More News

  • New treatment options for anaphylaxis

    New treatment options for anaphylaxis

    Two new emergency treatment options will become available in Victorian schools to support students at risk of anaphylaxis. Education Minister Ben Carroll announced the two new services will soon become…

  • Inquiry into anti-LGBTIQA+ hate crimes

    Inquiry into anti-LGBTIQA+ hate crimes

    The Victorian Parliament’s Legal and Social Issues Committee is moving forward with a formal inquiry into anti-LGBTIQA+ hate crimes. The investigation is designed to analyse the frequency of targeted attacks,…

  • Festival for all abilities

    Festival for all abilities

    Ability Fest is returning to Melbourne on April 11, 2026, with a new focus on industrial venue accessibility at The Timber Yard in Port Melbourne. The event marks a shift…

  • The sport of kings in Werribee

    The sport of kings in Werribee

    What many call the sport of kings will be on full display at Werribee Park as the historic Urquhart Cup polo tournament gallops into town on Sunday 1 March. More…

  • Lions through

    Lions through

    Deer Park will be hoping to go one better after winning through to the Victorian Turf Cricket Association group A T20 grand finals. Last year’s runners-up, the Lions sent a…

  • Ballan Autumn Festival’s landmark event

    Ballan Autumn Festival’s landmark event

    Ballan’s favourite community festival is set to return for its 50th annual event on Sunday 15 March, celebrating local culture, creativity, and community. The Ballan Autumn Festival is one of…

  • Hillside man arrested

    Hillside man arrested

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 206998 Police arrested a 19-year old Hillside man and seized drugs and cash following a crash in Port Melbourne on Thursday 19 February. Officers…

  • Brimbank scientist nominated for award

    Brimbank scientist nominated for award

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 534495 Brimbank resident Yemima Ehrnst has been nominated for the 7NEWS Young Achiever Awards (YAA) for her work furthering investigations in green energy. As…

  • Concerns over proposed facility

    Concerns over proposed facility

    A new application for a pork rendering facility in Laverton North has raised concerns among Brimbank residents, who fear it could worsen ongoing odour issues in the area. Submitted by…

  • Festival of colour returns

    Festival of colour returns

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 535459 Brimbank is set to come alive with colour, music, and community spirit as the much-loved Holi Festival returns for its third consecutive year.…